|
Gastric bypass long term weight loss S.O.S. (Swedish Obesity Study) results |
|
The reason some doctors say WLS is the
only weight loss solution which works is because the average WLS patient
(unlike the average patient on a diet) does not gain it all back.
However, as shown in this clinical study, WLS may only give the patient a
small advantage over dieters. Although medicine considers this advantage
to be significant but it may not be what most patients who wish to be
"slim" would like to expect. (The Hebrew University study showed
that only 7 percent of gastric bypass patients kept all the weight off -
70 percent kept SOME weight off and 25 percent regained all.)
Here are some of the results of the
only long term clinical study of WLS that we know about. It's called the
Swedish Obesity Study. In the New England Journal of Medicine, some of
the results were published. This is a clinical study of over 641
patients, and has been ongoing for ten years.
The weight loss results were:
at the 2 year point post op: the
average loss was 23 percent of the patient's weight.
at the 10 year point post op, the
average loss had dropped to 16 percent of the patient's weight.
Here is a projection of expected
weights for the average gastric bypass patient according to the Swedish
Obesity study:
SOS weight results
start wt 2 years 10 years 300 231 252 350 270 294 400 308 336 450 346.5 378 500 385 420
As reference to diabetes:
At the two year point, 72 percent
of the diabetics appeared to be recovered but at the 10 year point,
only 36 percent of the diabetics were still "disease-free".
Although we certainly rejoice with
those new ops who show amazing weight losses, the results of the only
ongoing clinical long term study of WLS patients are a bit more
sobering than the ads or seminars. Remember those who hang out in ANY
diet group, INCLUDING WLS support groups, are the small percentage who
can keep all or most of their weight off - the average people who
usually have more significant regains, are not the ones they parade to
sell the diet.
SOURCE: New England Journal of
Medicine: Volume 351:2683-2693 December 23, 2004 Number 26
Lifestyle, Diabetes, and Cardiovascular Risk Factors 10 Years after Bariatric Surgery Lars Sjostrom, M.D., Ph.D et al
|